Surely we should be trying to establish a culture in which being beautiful isn’t the primary currency of value?

http://www.dailylife.com.au/news-and-views/dl-opinion/why-the-war-on-photoshopping-is-a-distraction-20120823-24o05.html

Good for Clementine Ford at Daily Life*, Australia (see the link above). I really agree with her points here on PR stunts in fashion and media (publishing images of women with wrinkles, banning low BMIs on the catwalk) and on ‘Real Woman’ marketing. Why, when changes are made to policy on photoshopping and airbrushing, do editorial boards gently switch back to the emaciated and sand-coloured model? They’re obviously PR stunts, flighty and fashionable gestures that could win a magazine new supporters, but don’t count after one issue.

It’s also incredibly contradictory to promote ‘real’ women (I think that means you are ‘curvy’, ‘hourglass’ etc), while selling a product which supposedly makes you even more beautiful, flawless, perfect (as with the Dove campaign).

I think her feature provokes a really interesting question – is it better to promote diversity within marketing of the ‘beautiful woman’ or not?

You could argue that more diverse portrayals of women within mass marketing and media is an important, and these are tiny steps towards a greater goal. However, I’d agree with Clementine that being beautiful, in any guise, shouldn’t be the primary currency, and I also think the channels in which these tiny steps are made (banning size zero etc) are inappropriate.

If we want ‘real’ women, we’re never going to find them on a billboard or a glossy magazine, it’s crazy for us to go on this unfulfilling manhunt. It’s crazy for us to compare ourselves to catwalk models even if they are more ‘curvy’, and similarly crazy to think that a woman in a Burberry advert is anything like ourselves, even if she has a higher BMI.

It would be more appropriate to promote looking at our friends and family for inspiration about what being a woman really is, rather than looking at the warped media, marketing and fashion worlds.

(*It’s a shame the Daily Life is saturated in beauty/healthcare ads).

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “Surely we should be trying to establish a culture in which being beautiful isn’t the primary currency of value?

  1. I’m starting a local magazine in my hometown promoting local women and what they’re up to in the community and Jess Barlow of the Cleo petition and The Brainwash Project (mentioned in this article) has written some great articles for me. She is so inspiring!! You can check out The Brainwash Project on wordpress. She really is making waves in the media world at the moment, with hundreds of people writing to Cleo Australia’s facebook change. 🙂
    The more women around the globe who kick up a stink about photoshop and glorifying ‘beauty’ the better I say!
    Love your analysis and thoughts on the article 🙂 and enjoying your blog!
    Laura
    xo

    http://www.thecupthief.wordpress.com

    1. Thanks Laura, much appreciated. I’ll definitely look into The Brainwash Project and will be following Cleo’s work. So glad to see so many young female writers focused on feminism, and will be following thecupthief! Alice x

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s